CONTENT WARNING FOR MENTION OF TRANSPHOBIA AND TRANSMISOGYNY
I am a cis woman and I’m about to write about transness. Before I begin I would like to make it clear that I support my trans brethren. Trans rights are human rights, trans identities are valid, trans women are women, trans men are men, and non-binary people are exactly who they say they are.
I am not going to tell a trans story. It’s not my place as a cis person to tell a trans story. I’m here to write about the experience of watching the transformation that happens when a trans person becomes their truest self and the envy I feel.
Recently I’ve watched as two people I like and admire came out, one as gender fluid and the other as a trans woman. I was happy for them, and struck by how much happier they seem, but also by how pretty they are. How are they so pretty after such a short time taking hormones? I’ve been on estrogen my whole life and I look like a boot.
Incidentally I think that question might be behind some of the transmisogyny and transphobia aimed at trans women by so-called feminists. There’s this stab of rage that you can feel if you’re not happy with your own appearance and you’re faced with a trans woman who is just blossoming as she becomes who she always was. Why does she get to feel whole when I don’t? She’s not a proper woman. She doesn’t even have a uterus. Which is bullshit, of course. Trans women are not responsible for your (or my) low self esteem. They absolutely are women and no woman requires a uterus.
Some of you reading this are already thinking that this must mean that I’m trans and in denial. Nope. I’m definitely a woman. I already am my truest self. It’s just that I don’t like who that is. I’m not looking at trans men and wishing that I could be a man too. When I look at non binary and gender fluid people I see some amazing aesthetics that I’d love to be able to pull off but I don’t see an identity that I aspire to.
I do want to transition but I want to transition into a woman that I actually like. I ache to be able to smile at the person in the mirror without faking it. I yearn for a body that feels like it belongs to me.
I don’t know what it’s like for other chronically ill people but for me it feels like I’ve been at war with my own body for a long time. It causes me pain, constantly, and I hurt it back by insisting on moving around and doing things. It would be so much easier to just lie down and die but I’m not going to give the bastard the satisfaction.
My body has no redeeming features. I look like a potato, I move like a badly made marionette, nothing fits and I’m never comfortable. And there’s not a thing I can do about it. There’s no surgery or pills that can fix my body or how I feel about it.
Which is one thing that I do have in common with many trans people. A lot of trans people aren’t taking hormones or getting surgeries. Some of them don’t want to do either, which is absolutely fine, but many more are blocked by lack of money or by medical gatekeepers. They shouldn’t have to suffer when the remedy for that suffering exists. They definitely shouldn’t be suffering just because no remedy for my suffering exists.
I suppose that I’m really talking about that suffering. I suffer because of my shonky body, and my terrible self esteem, but that terrible self esteem didn’t spring up out of nowhere. It comes from being told that my body isn’t what it should be. It also comes from my body not being equal to the tasks required of it. I suffer because of the constant gap between what I am and what I feel I ought to be. I can’t ever bridge that gap, and no-one should expect me to but I still feel the weight of that expectation. There’s also this unconscious expectation of a transformation. Stories are full of people discovering strange new abilities, of spontaneously transforming into some new form. I have this unconscious expectation that I should be transforming, that I should be finding some inner strength or previously unknown power.
I want to say that such a thing just doesn’t happen but then I look at trans people and it feels like that’s what they’re doing, even though many of them talk about it as revealing who they truly are rather than becoming something new.
As I’ve said before, my problem is that I don’t like who I truly am. What I truly am is disabled, dependent and limited. I can’t do half the things I want to and I’m having trouble accepting that because my mind keeps insisting that it’s just temporary. I need to somehow get over this because it’s keeping me from doing the things that I am capable of while I’m still capable of them.
Maybe the real problem is that I don’t see myself represented anywhere in the media. Disabled people only ever get to be victims, or monsters, and in order to be victims they need to be disabled in ways that are more visible and more socially acceptable. I don’t see myself anywhere except in the mirror. It’s no wonder that I can’t smile at the woman I see there. She’s a stranger.